From popular sovereignty to the sovereignty of law 9780520067981. Popular sovereignty was a political doctrine that the united states subscribed during the midnineteenth century, which stated that the settlers of a given territory would have the sole right to. The first and most important example of popular sovereignty is the constitution itself. Popular sovereignty is a doctrine rooted in the belief that each citizen has sovereignty over themselves. In the time of popular sovereignty, paulina ochoa espejo clears away centuries of conceptual clutter, showing a keen awareness of the paradoxes that plague this project. The traditional statist framework of international law has been challenged, first by ideas of universal human rights and corollary pleas for cosmopolitan democracy, and then by emergent claims to imperial sovereignty made by the united states and its allies. Popular sovereignty is a doctrine rooted in the belief that each citizen has sovereignty over. May 02, 2014 why was popular sovereignty so controversial. How did the creation of popular sovereignty in the new. Popular sovereignty was one of the ideas that featured in the antebellum political. Popular sovereignty united states american history. Popular sovereignty books meet your next favorite book.
Few revolutionary concepts are expressed as succinctly as the principle contained in the first three words of the united states constitution. Popular sovereignty definition of popular sovereignty by. It called for organizing territories without mention of slavery, thus leaving it to local settlers to determine the status of slavery among them. Popular sovereignty definition, the doctrine that sovereign power is vested in the people and that those chosen to govern, as trustees of such power, must exercise it in. Popular sovereignty simple english wikipedia, the free. This concept was used several times throughout american history. Popular sovereignty revolves around the idea that the people of a specific countryterritory get to decide on certain issues. Stephen arnold douglas was an american politician from illinois and the designer of the kansasnebraska act. Calhoun and that designation was adopted by its critics, which included proslavery southerners and many new englanders. Jul 30, 2019 popular sovereignty was often cited before the us civil war as a reason why individuals in a newly organized territory should have the right to decide whether or not slavery should be allowed. The idea of popular sovereignty was tested quickly in the years after the mexicanamerican war.
Introduced the kansasnebraska act to further the construction of a transcontinental railroad. Newly created territories in antebellum america were designed to be extensions of national sovereignty and jurisdiction. Bleeding kansas was an example of popular sovereignty before the civil war. Opposition was intense, but ultimately the bill passed in may of 1854. The us congress passed the 1854 kansasnebraska act called for the use of popular sovereignty to determine whether a territory would enter the union as a free or slave state. Promoters of a transcontinental railroad were also pushing for this westward expansion. This belief is based on the concept that the government should exist for the sole purpose of benefiting its citizens, and if the government is not doing everything it can to protect its people, then it should be disbanded. Popular sovereignty was the ruinous policy intended to let the will of the people on the ground determine the expansion of slavery before the civil war.
Eventually, the controversy over slavery and popular sovereignty helped give birth to a new political party. Popular sovereignty definition of popular sovereignty at. Douglas was the champion of popular sovereignty, of letting states and territories decide for themselves whether to legalize slavery. Another example of popular sovereignty can be found in the ratification of the 26th amendment to the constitution. Green on childers, the failure of popular sovereignty. What was a provision of the constitution that clearly reflects the principle of popular sovereignty.
Stephen douglas introduces popular sovereignty to the united states in the years leading up to the civil war. Determine the number of senators new slave states may send to congress c. Polk ran for president in 1844, he ran on a platform of expansion, specifically promising to secure us claims to the oregon territory and to annex texas, california, and new mexico. This chapter examines the concept of popular sovereignty and what exactly it means for the people to rule in relation to democracy and elections. The idea of popular sovereignty as it pertains to the extension of slavery to the territories in the antebellum era was a political concept that allowed the residents of the territories themselves, rather than congress, to determine whether to permit or prohibit slavery. In the compromise of 1850, the new mexico and utah territories used popular sovereignty in order to decide whether or not slavery existed in their territories. Aug 21, 2018 the kansasnebraska act was an 1854 bill that mandated popular sovereigntyallowing settlers of a territory to decide whether slavery would be allowed within a new states borders. The federal government did not have to make a decision about slaverys existence in territories such as kansas and nebraska. How does popular sovereignty affects us today answers.
Nov, 2017 in general, popular sovereignty means the voice of the people. Popular sovereignty in early modern constitutional thought. Alternatively, the people could be said to rule if policy is made and. Lincoln drew a moral line, arguing that slavery was a violation both of natural law and of the principles expressed in the declaration of independence. Lewis cass of michigan, democratic candidate for president in the election of 1848, coined the term popular sovereignty. This term is usually used in reference to political issues that are settled by popular vote or to governments based on the concept of democracy. During 19th century it was a compromise used to determine if a. Popular sovereignty definition and meaning collins english.
Territory north of the sacred 3630 line was now open to popular sovereignty. The times literary supplement 2017 according to the later chapters of this book, popular sovereignty would not cease to preside. If the government is not protecting the people, says the declaration of. It is closely associated with social contract philosophers such as thomas hobbes, john locke and jeanjacques rousseau.
To some moderates, slavery in the territories was not a matter for congress to resolve. Popular sovereignty, slavery in the territories, and the south, 1785. Popular sovereignty in the united states simple english. Americans founded their revolution and government on popular sovereignty, but the term was also used in the 1850s to describe a highly controversial approach to slavery in the territories as propounded by senator stephen a. By this simple phrasing the federal constitution institutionalized the revolution principle that had rejected the sovereignty of kinginparliament and replaced it with a structure embodying the sovereignty of the. Whenever the united states enlarged its territorial domain, leaders naturally.
Sovereignty and treaties before going into the exploration of the article and how it pertains to sovereignty and treaties, lets define those two terms. Popular sovereignty was well supported because it allowed the local citizens of a territory to decide if slavery was to be allowed or illegal. The kansasnebraska act allowed white male settlers in kansas and nebraska to decide, through popular. Supreme court rejected popular sovereignty in dred scott v. The dividing line between federal and local authority by stephen a douglas online at alibris. Popular sovereignty definition and meaning collins. Popular sovereignty definition is a doctrine in political theory that government is created by and subject to the will of the people. The idea of popular sovereignty dates back to midseventeenth to the eighteenth century through the famous writer jean rousseau. Popular sovereignty was used in eastern europe to create several countries. Popular sovereignty in its modern sense, is an idea that dates to the social contracts school mid17th to mid18th centuries, represented by thomas hobbes 15881679, john locke 16321704, and jeanjacques rousseau 17121778, author of the social contract, a prominent political work that clearly highlighted the ideals of general. It meant that people living in a territory would be the ones to decide if slavery would be allowed. The kansasnebraska act of 1854 was based on the ideathat people have a right to property in the form of slaves.
In the united states, the term has been used to express this concept. In addition to the good information in the above post, popular sovereignty was part of the compromise hammered out in 1850, largely by senator henry clay, which allowed texas in as a slave state. It was first applied in organizing the utah and new mexico territories in 1850. Full text of popular sovereignty in the territories. Popular sovereignty was asserted as a founding principle of the united states of america. What was stephen douglas popular sovereignty answers. No longer was the question of slavery in the new territories hypothetical. Proposed that the status of slavery in the new territories be governed by the principle of popular sovereignty.
Popular sovereignty in the territories by douglas, stephen arnold, 181861. In general, popular sovereignty means the voice of the people. Popular sovereignty should settle the slavery question 1858. The declaration of independence of 1776 asserts that legitimate governments are those deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed. Resolve the issue of slavery in newly acquired us territories b. Created territories of kansas and nebraska and repealed the compromise of 1820. The very title of bruce ackermans now threevolume masterwork, we the people, signifies his commitment to popular sovereignty and, beyond that, to the embrace of democratic inclusion as the leitmotif of american constitutionalism.
Popular sovereignty constituitional principle the government is based on the peoples consent this is why the preamble starts with we the people amd ends with do ordain and establish this constitution for the united states of america. A major consequence of popular sovereigntys application was the rush by both pro and antislavery forces to populate kansas and determine its fate, which manifested in violence and fraud. Popular sovereignty article about popular sovereignty by. Congress lacked the authority to exclude slavery from the territoriesa decision that many people argued made slavery legal in all territories regardless of the desires of their inhabitants. Citizens may unite and offer to delegate a portion of their sovereign powers and duties to those who wish to serve as officers of the state, contingent on the officers agreeing to serve according to the will of the people. What law allowed popular sovereignty in several us. But popular sovereignty, not to mention democracy, has many conceptions, and there is a tension within ackermans overall project as to which of the. In the long run the principle of popular sovereignty proved to be most unsatisfactory of all, making each territory a battleground where the supporters of the south contended with the defenders of the north and west. How did the idea of popular sovereignty in kansas and. The concept of popular sovereignty manifested itself during the. In 1846, the wilmot proviso, which sought to forbid slavery in the territories acquired following the mexicanamerican war, died on the floor of the senate. Popular sovereignty in the united states wikipedia. Howwhy did the annexation of mexican territory push the. Oct 16, 20 why the founders belief in the popular sovereignty.
The compromise of 1850 was an uneasy patchwork of concessions to all sides that began to fall apart as soon as it was enacted. Douglas, of popular sovereignty, nearly cost him her sup. Popular sovereignty definition, meaning, examples, cases. He urged it as a solution to the question of slavery in the territories. It stemmed out of the fact that eighteenyearolds were serving in the vietnam war and the people figured that if a young man can fight for his country then he should be. Make sure that citizens of new states could decide whether or not to allow slavery by popular sovereignty. In the heat of the wilmot proviso debate, many southern lawmakers began to question the right of congress to determine the status of slavery in any territory. The act also applied the principle of popular sovereignty, dictating that the. Popular sovereignty civil war on the western border. In 1854, the kansasnebraska act was passed, allowing the kansas and nebraska territories to decide for themselves using popular sovereignty whether they wanted to be free or slave. Popular sovereignty is in danger of being sealed off from ordinary citizens, caught in a loop between the people and its representatives. Sovereignty can be described as a state having complete control over its boundaries. Popular sovereignty is the principle that the authority of a state and its government are created and sustained by the consent of its people, through their elected representatives rule by the people, who are the source of all political power. Popular sovereignty and the rights of the people were undoubtedly a concern, 52 and a popular sovereignty interpretation of the tenth amendment was explicitly part of its ratifying debate.
In this way, the term popular sovereignty became part of the rhetoric for leaving it up to residents of the american territories to decide whether or not to accept or reject slavery. Popular sovereignty is a political term that simply means that the people are the rulers. Douglas and created the territories of kansas and nebraska and opened new lands for settlement. In essence, this also left it up to the people of the territories to resolve the controversy over expansion of slavery in the united states. Cass is best known as the father of popular sovereignty, the notion that the sovereign people of a territory should themselves decide the issue of slavery.
Concept of sovereignty revisited european journal of. Popular sovereignty was a political doctrine in the united states that held that the people who lived in a state or region should decide what kind of government or laws they should have. Although the doctrine won wide support as a means of avoiding sectional conflict over the slavery issue, its meaning remained ambiguous, since proponents disagreed as to the stage of territorial development at which the decision should be made. Constitution proclaimed popular sovereignty in the. The 1854 kansasnebraska act popular sovereignty was an important feature of the 1854 kansasnebraska act which was drafted by stephen a. The rise of abolitionism during the 1830s, coupled with a renewed push to organize the territorial domain, fueled growth of a. Popular sovereignty and the slavery issue for kids. One definition of popular sovereignty takes ruling as a physical act to be performed by the people themselves, rather than something that is delegated to a smaller political class. Each of the two great political parties was a vital bond of national unity, for each enjoyed powerful support in both north and south.
Popular sovereignty is a doctrine rooted in the belief that every human being is sovereign, and rather than a monarch or single individual, that they could unite and each delegate a small portion of their sovereign powers and duties to those who wished to temporarily serve as officers and employees of a state, who would serve the rest of the people according to the will of the people expressed. We have new and used copies available, in 0 edition. This amendment lowered the legal voting age from 21 to 18. Of course, the great issue between lincoln and douglas was slavery. It can be considered one of the long term causes of the civil war. The hope by douglas and other proponents of popular sovereignty that its application to new territories could preserve the union was soon dashed. Apr 01, 2006 the traditional statist framework of international law has been challenged, first by ideas of universal human rights and corollary pleas for cosmopolitan democracy, and then by emergent claims to imperial sovereignty made by the united states and its allies. Popular sovereignty the doctrine that the public powers of state originate in a concessive grant of power from the people is perhaps the cardinal doctrine of modern constitutional theory, placing full constitutional authority in the people at large, rather than in the hands of judges, kings, or a political elite. Sandford 1857, declaring that slavery could enter any territory, but neither. Im utterly confused as to why this was so controversial other than the fact that it gave the people the right to abolish or enforce slavery. He was a major politician and an equality activist who, in his book entitled the social contract, brought about the beginning of general will. Finally living out american popular sovereignty is vital to the trajectory of the entire world at this time in history.
View notes popular sovereignty from amh amh2010 at broward college. This tenet is based on the concept of the social contract, the idea that government should be for the benefit of its citizens. Popular sovereignty essential civil war curriculum. What does it mean to be in a republican government where there is no popular sovereignty. Popular sovereignty popular sovereignty is the contention that the uni. The concept of popular sovereignty developed in the 19th century as a means of dealing with new us territories and the issues of slavery. Squatter, or popular, sovereignty was an idea hatched by michigan senator lewis cass in 1848. He proposed that the nebraska territory be divided into two territories nebraska and kansas. Its enemies, especially in new england, called it squatter sovereignty. The issue would reemerge with the push for creating the territory of nebraska. First promoted in the 1840s in response to debates over western expansion, popular sovereignty argued that in a democracy, residents of a territory, and not the federal government, should be allowed to decide on slavery within their borders. Politicians proposed popular sovereignty as a means of entrusting the issue to citizens of new territories childers now uses popular sovereignty as a lens for viewing the radicalization of southern states rights politics politicians from north and south redesigned popular sovereignty to lessen sectional tensions to rethink the concept of popular sovereignty beyond the nationstate.
According to our book, pg 40 sovereignty includes such essentials as selfdetermination, nonintervention, and equality. Americans created their revolution and government on popular sovereignty. Popular sovereignty is the idea that the government gets its power from its citizens. He engaged in a series of eloquent debates with republican senate candidate abraham lincoln in 1858. This is the very document that gives the common people power and protects their rights from an oppressive government and instead allows for one ruled by the people, for the people. Utah territory, however, was a deeply contested space in which a cohesive settler groupthe mormonssought to establish their own popular sovereignty, raising the question of who possessed and could exercise. Yale law journal popular sovereignty and the united states. Leading up to the adoption of what became the ninth and tenth amendments was a robust debate about the rights and powers of the people, states, and federal. The initial purpose of it was to create opportunities for a mideastern transcontinental railroad. What is the significance of popular sovereignty in us history. In the bill, he suggested that the decision about whether to allow slavery in each of these two territories be settled by popular sovereignty. It allowed settlers of a territory to decide for themselves on the question of slavery without any interference from the federal government. Douglas then proposed that the upcoming territories would be decided by popular sovereignty, earning the souths favor and thus, removing the missouri compromise. Forbid the expansion of slavery into newly acquired territories d.
By 1856, kansas had become a hotbed of violence as pro and antislavery forces fought over the states future to the point where it was nicknamed bleeding kansas. Douglas, american politician, leader of the democratic party, and orator who espoused the cause of popular sovereignty in relation to the issue of slavery in the territories before the civil war. The popular sovereignty principle is one of the underlying ideas of the united states constitution, and it argues that the source of governmental power sovereignty lies with the people popular. The term was also used in the 1850s to describe a very controversial way to deal with slavery in the territories. Opposed the lecompton constitution on the grounds that it violated popular sovereignty. Popular sovereignty in the united states infogalactic. As responsible sovereigns, we must learn to graduate from social media slacktivism futile likes and views. The purpose of this publication is to exhibit the democratic record, us it was made by the repre sentative men of tho partv, on the doctrine of popul. Popular sovereignty was first termed asquatter sovereigntya by john c. Popular sovereignty and slavery american historama. The purpose of this publication is simply to exhibit the democratic record, as it was made by the representative men of the party, on the doctrine of popular sovereignty in the territories. According to john calhoun, the territories belonged to all the. Popular sovereignty in 19 th century america emerged as a compromise strategy for determining whether a western territory would permit or prohibit slavery. Zachary taylor 17841850 military general and twelfth u.
1154 1532 270 628 1079 964 1344 130 228 691 238 1467 135 540 690 898 1402 106 57 1359 725 90 1626 761 888 1270 1563 146 1135 1618 855 548 709 622 121 942 1044 57 1201 1429 813